Natural sciences, Physics and Chemistry, have provided us two basic laws of thermodynamics that are claimed to be obeyed by all forms of matter and energy, including living organisms.
The first law of thermodynamics is about “conservation of matter and energy,” which states that matter and energy can neither be created nor destroyed. Matter and energy can be transformed, and energy can be converted from one form into another, but the total of the equivalent amounts of both must always remain constant. When energy gets converted from one form into another, inevitably some of it is given off as heat.
The second law of thermodynamics is about “entropy increases” which states that all forms of energy tend to change spontaneously into a more dispersed, random, or less organized, form. This law defines entropy as a phenomenon of energy being constantly getting random, unavailable. Suppose you heat a pan to cook an egg, and after finishing you leave it on the stove. After some time the pan has cooled to air temperature, and the heat energy has radiated throughout the room. That heat energy is now dispersed and unavailable for cooking; the system of the pan, the room, and the heat has gone toward equilibrium. This tendency to move towards equilibrium reduces the useful availability of the energy.
An outside source of energy, with fuel or electricity, is continually required to maintain a non-equilibrium state, dispersion of heat results in a random equilibrium state. The same is true for all kinds of energy. According to second law of thermodynamics, our solar system and presumably the entire universe should theoretically become a completely random over-dispersed array of molecules and heat in the far distant future.
The more well-known first law of thermodynamics has very little to do with the energy future of our civilization. We can have all the energy in the world, but if this energy is not in a sufficiently concentrated form, it is physically impossible to make it do any meaningful work for us.
Heat Engine is the result of second law of thermodynamics. The implications of the second law of thermodynamics as it applies to our energy future is this: energy will always try to move from more concentrated forms to less concentrated forms and can only be made to do some useful work during this transition. This Second Law of Thermodynamics, developed during the 19th century, is said to be the only principle of Newtonian physics that survived the Einsteinian revolution. It is therefore an important and respected law which has a great bearing on our energy future.
Fossil fuels contain energy in concentrated form and, by burning these fuels (freeing this concentrated energy to disperse as heat throughout the biosphere) the heat engines deliver the meaningful work. In the process, however, some of the energy inevitably becomes “inaccessible” as “waste” or low-grade heat. Once dispersed, this energy achieves a state of high disorder or entropy. It cannot be reused, renewed, or recycled because it would take “more energy to reassemble it than could be recovered”. Since the thermal efficiency of the best heat engines today is around 50%, we shall always be getting waste heat (in addition to other toxic effluents) from these engines as un-available energy.
The gasoline in an automobile engine, for example, transforms into mechanical motion. As it is consumed, however, some energy is inevitably thrown off as engine heat or friction against the road. Eventually all the momentum of your car will eventually be transformed into low-grade heat. The energy is still out there but it cannot be recycled or renewed. Therefore the tank will need a refill.
Calling some sources of energy “renewable” should not be confused with the concept that waste heat or disordered and diffused energy can be reused. It can never happen and it is against the laws of natural sciences. Thinking like that would be very misleading. What is really meant by renewable energy is that some forms of energy are inexhaustible, at least for our purposes. The energy of the sun is inexhaustible with respect to life on the planet. But it is not infinite. Even when we use renewable energy, we get some of the waste heat. But this waste does not harm the environment. The reason is simple. The renewable energy systems like, concentrated solar power plants, simply concentrates the energy available in the environment for producing useful work. These systems do not burn matter to create energy.
Similarly, Hydroelectricity derives from the sun’s power to evaporate water and return it as rain. Wind comes from the sun’s uneven heating of the atmosphere. The great advantage of solar electricity is that it is strongest when it is needed most — on hot summer afternoons when electrical demand peaks. Solar electricity could definitely relieve natural gas peaking plants in powering our summer air conditioning. For this purpose we may have to prefer Concentrated Solar Power systems over PV cell systems, making a system more efficient.
There is one other source of renewable energy that is close to being as inexhaustible as the sun. That is nuclear power, which might be called “terrestrial energy.” Our planet generates huge amounts of heat. The temperature in its interior — 7,000 degrees C. — is hotter than the surface of the sun. What is the source of this heat? Some of it comes from the pressures of gravitational collapse, but almost half is generated by the disintegration of two tiny elements, uranium and thorium.
Terrestrial Energy is tapped at geothermal sites, where heat from the earth’s molten core comes in contact with groundwater. We perform this same heat exchange in what is called a “nuclear reactor.” A nuclear plant is simply the duplication of a geothermal site under more controlled conditions. Terrestrial energy does not rely on solar energy stored in carbon bonds and therefore does not put carbon dioxide back into the atmosphere. It is about as “green” as energy can get. It can probably stand by itself but is definitely worth including in any portfolio of “clean, renewable energy.”
REVERSE ENTROPY
Life is sometimes called “reverse entropy” (negentropy) because organisms maintain complex organized non-random states compared to their surroundings. But they must obey the second law of thermodynamics just as any other system of matter and energy; all organisms must work continually to build and maintain nonrandom assemblages of matter and energy locally. This process requires energy, and organisms use the energy of the decaying sun (which, of course, also obeys the second law of thermodynamics and tends toward decreasing concentration of energy) to “oppose” the second law within their own tissues by concentrating energy in their own bodies. Wherever there is a live plant or animal, there must be an energy source. Without a continued influx of energy, no organism can survive for very long. Again, this “reverse entropy” occurs only within each organism, and the overall energy relations of the entire solar system are in accord with the second law of thermodynamics, with the overall system continually becoming more and more random.
Almost all life on Earth depends on photo-synthesis, the capture of solar energy by plants. Chloroplasts are the tiny green engines that house chlorophyll and other molecular machinery enabling plants to convert solar energy into the chemical energy on which all life on Earth depends.
We may conclude fairly that laws of nature or thermodynamics are not a measure of cleanliness or greenness of any form of energy usage. Nature has created abundant energy resources and has demonstrated that all energy available cannot be converted to useful work. The waste is inherent in the nature, and the nature has its own reasons for keeping the systems like this. What we should concentrate on is not to artificially increase the rate of ENTROPY or unavailability of the energy. In my opinion, the best part of the Green Energy Living is the slowing down of the rate of energy disorder.